How to Use Anal Plugs — A Complete Guide for Sydney
How to Use Anal Plugs
Anal plugs are one of the most popular and most beginner-friendly categories in the entire anal toy range — yet they're also one of the most misunderstood, often approached with unnecessary anxiety or, conversely, with not enough care. Whether you're completely new to anal play or looking to expand your knowledge after some initial exploration, this guide covers everything: the anatomy behind why they feel good, exactly how to use one safely and comfortably, how to choose the right size for where you're starting, the different types available, and answers to the questions Sydney customers ask us most often.
Quick links:
- Why anal plugs feel good — the anatomy
- Types of anal plugs explained
- How to choose the right size and material
- How to use an anal plug step by step
- Our top Sydney picks
- Wearing a plug during other activities
- Cleaning and care
- Frequently asked questions
Why Anal Plugs Feel Good — The Anatomy
Understanding the anatomy behind anal pleasure removes a lot of the mystery — and most of the unnecessary anxiety — that surrounds this category. The anal canal is densely packed with nerve endings, particularly concentrated in the first few centimetres near the entrance. This nerve density is the reason even a relatively small plug can produce significant sensation — the area doesn't need to be fully "filled" or deeply penetrated to be meaningfully stimulated.
The anal sphincter itself plays a central role in the sensation of plug use. There are actually two sphincter muscles — the external sphincter (under voluntary control) and the internal sphincter (involuntary, responsive to relaxation and arousal). A plug works partly by providing gentle, sustained pressure that encourages these muscles to relax while maintaining a sense of fullness and stretch. It's this sustained, gentle pressure sensation that most users describe as uniquely pleasurable and distinct from any other type of stimulation.
For people with a prostate
For men and people with a prostate, anal plugs that press against the anterior (front) wall of the rectum can provide indirect prostate stimulation — not the direct, targeted pressure of a purpose-built prostate massager, but a diffuse, sustained stimulation of the surrounding area that many users describe as adding a layer of intensity to any other stimulation happening simultaneously.
For everyone
The anal nerve endings are connected to the broader pelvic nerve network, which also serves the genitals. This is why anal stimulation during other sexual activity — whether solo or partnered, whether vibrating stimulation or penetration — often significantly intensifies overall arousal and orgasm for people of all anatomies.
Types of Anal Plugs Explained
Classic tapered plugs
The most universally recommended starting point — a smooth, tapered shape that narrows at the neck before widening to a flared base. The taper allows gradual insertion, the neck holds the plug comfortably in place once inserted (sitting against the sphincter), and the flared base prevents the plug from travelling further than intended. Simple, effective, and the design most plug beginners should start with. The Selopa Petite Plug is a well-designed example at a very accessible entry price.
Jewelled and decorative plugs
Functionally identical to classic tapered plugs, but with decorative gemstone or crystal bases that add an aesthetic element to the experience. Particularly popular for partnered use and for those who want their toys to feel as beautiful as they are functional. The Gender X Gold Digger and the Silver Starter are examples at different price points, both featuring gem-set bases in striking finishes.
Vibrating plugs
Plugs with one or more built-in vibrating motors, adding direct stimulation to the sustained fullness sensation a standard plug provides. Vibration can be felt throughout the anal canal and in the surrounding pelvic area, intensifying the experience considerably compared to a non-vibrating plug. USB rechargeable options with multiple patterns and intensities — like the Evolved Lieutenant and the Evolved Mighty Mini — offer a wide adjustable range for different moods and experience levels.
Remote-controlled vibrating plugs
Vibrating plugs that include a wireless remote, allowing a partner to control intensity and patterns without the wearer needing to reach for the toy. The Selopa The Colonel is a remote-controlled vibrating plug specifically designed for this kind of partnered or public play — discreet enough to wear under clothing, with a partner adjusting the experience from a distance.
Weighted plugs
Metal or glass plugs with significant weight that creates a distinct, gravity-responsive fullness sensation as the wearer moves. Popular with experienced plug users who want a different sensory profile to silicone or plastic options. Also useful for temperature play — metal and glass can be warmed or cooled before use.
How to Choose the Right Size and Material
Size for beginners
The single most consistent advice from every sexual health professional and experienced practitioner in this space: start considerably smaller than you think you need to. A plug that feels genuinely small is almost always the right choice for a first experience — the Selopa Petite Plug at 7.4cm total length and a modest insertable diameter is about right. You will have ample opportunity to size up in future sessions once you've built familiarity and comfort. Starting too large is the most common reason first-time plug use is uncomfortable rather than pleasurable.
The flared base rule — non-negotiable
Every anal plug must have a flared base wider than the widest part of the plug body, or a retrieval cord. This is not a preference — it's a safety requirement. The anal canal, unlike the vagina, has no natural stopping point and will draw objects inward. Every product in Sex Toys Sydney's anal plug range meets this requirement. If you ever encounter an anal toy without a proper flared base, do not use it anally regardless of what it's marketed as.
Material recommendations
Body-safe silicone is the default recommendation for beginners and most general use — soft, flexible, non-porous, and easy to clean. ABS plastic is a firmer, less flexible alternative that also rates as body-safe. Metal (stainless steel) and glass are non-porous, fully sterilisable, and excellent for temperature play, but firmer and heavier than silicone — better suited to those who already know they enjoy plug use and want to explore different sensory profiles. Avoid any plug that doesn't clearly state its material.
How to Use an Anal Plug — Step by Step
Step 1 — Choose your setting and timing
For your first time with an anal plug, choose a moment when you're genuinely relaxed, not rushed, and comfortable in your environment. Anxiety and rushing are the two biggest obstacles to a comfortable first experience, and both are entirely within your control through good timing. Many people find a warm shower or bath beforehand helps both hygiene and physical relaxation.
Step 2 — Clean the toy
Even brand new toys should be cleaned before first use. Wash with warm water and dedicated toy cleaner, rinse thoroughly, and dry completely before use. Browse Sex Toys Sydney's anal toy range which includes toy cleaner options.
Step 3 — Gather what you need before you start
Lubricant, the toy, and a clean towel within easy reach. You don't want to be searching for anything mid-session. The lubricant should be water-based or silicone-based — not oil-based, which degrades silicone toys.
Step 4 — Apply lubricant generously
This is not a step to be conservative with. Apply a generous amount of water-based anal lubricant to both the toy itself and the anal opening. The anal canal does not produce its own lubrication, so the lubricant you apply is everything. Under-lubrication is the leading cause of discomfort during anal play, and it's entirely preventable.
Step 5 — Begin with external touch
Before any insertion, spend a minute or two with gentle external touch around the anal opening. This isn't just about patience — it genuinely helps the sphincter relax and increases local blood flow and sensitivity, making the eventual insertion more comfortable and more pleasurable. Rushing past this step is one of the most common beginner mistakes.
Step 6 — Start insertion slowly at the tapered tip
Position the tip of the plug at the anal opening and apply gentle, consistent forward pressure — not a sharp push. Let the body accept the toy at its own pace. The external sphincter will relax with sustained gentle pressure; forcing past any resistance will cause discomfort and works against what you're trying to achieve. If you feel sharp pain at any point, stop, remove the toy, and reassess — sharp pain is always a stop signal.
Step 7 — Insert to the neck and let the sphincter settle
Once the widest part of the plug has passed the sphincter and the neck sits in place, the plug will hold its position naturally. Pause here for a moment and simply be with the sensation — the initial stretch and fullness feeling, which for most people settles into something more comfortable and pleasurable within 20–30 seconds as the body adjusts.
Step 8 — Adjust, move, or simply wear
Once the plug is comfortably in place, it can be worn statically, moved gently in and out, or worn during other sexual activity. If you have a vibrating plug, this is the point to switch it on — starting at the lowest setting and adjusting upward. For partnered play, this is when a partner can take over control.
Step 9 — Remove slowly and gently
Remove by bearing down slightly (as if using the bathroom) while gently drawing the plug outward. The widest point passing back through the sphincter will produce a distinct sensation — this is normal. Remove slowly rather than pulling quickly.
Step 10 — Clean immediately after
Clean the toy immediately after every use, before putting it away. Don't leave it unwashed — cleaning is easiest and most hygienic done immediately.
Our Top Anal Plug Picks — Available Now in Sydney
All ship same-day to Sydney on orders before 2pm AEST in completely plain unmarked packaging.
Selopa Petite Plug — Pink, 7.4cm — $19.99
The most accessible and most beginner-appropriate plug in our Sydney range. At 7.4cm total length with a genuinely modest insertable diameter and a smooth, tapered silicone body, this is the right starting point for anyone who hasn't used an anal plug before. Simple, comfortable, and at a price that removes any barrier to simply trying the category.
7.4cm total • Smooth tapered silicone • Beginner-perfect • Flared base • $19.99
The Silver Starter — Silver with Violet Heart Jewel, 7.1cm — $29.99
A beginner-friendly plug that adds a beautiful violet heart jewel base to the classic tapered design — an elegant aesthetic for those who want their toy to feel as much like jewellery as it does a sex toy. 7.1cm at an appropriately modest size for first-time use, with a secure flared base in the jewel setting.
7.1cm • Violet heart jewel base • Silver finish • Elegant aesthetic • $29.99
Gender X Gold Digger Small — Rose Gold with Black Gem Base — $39.99
A premium jewelled plug in a striking rose gold finish with a black gemstone base — one of the most visually beautiful plugs in our Sydney range. Small size, smooth body, and a luxurious aesthetic that makes it a popular choice for gifting as well as solo use. From the Gender X range, inclusive in design and sizing.
Small size • Rose gold finish • Black gem base • Premium aesthetic • $39.99
Evolved Lieutenant — Green, 12.2cm USB Rechargeable Vibrating Plug — $49.99
A vibrating step-up from a standard plug — adding motorised stimulation to the fullness sensation for a noticeably more intense experience. 12.2cm with multiple vibration modes and USB recharging. The vibration from the Evolved Lieutenant is felt throughout the anal canal and in the surrounding pelvic area, making it an excellent choice for those who've tried non-vibrating plugs and are ready for more.
12.2cm • Vibrating • Multiple modes • USB rechargeable • Green • $49.99
Selopa The Colonel — Green, 10.1cm USB Rechargeable Vibrating Plug with Remote — $79.99
A wireless remote-controlled vibrating plug for partnered or adventurous solo play — discreet enough to wear under clothing while a partner controls the experience remotely. USB rechargeable with multiple vibration patterns. The Colonel is Selopa's premium plug offering, and one of the most feature-complete options in the Sydney anal plug range at this price point.
10.1cm • Wireless remote • Vibrating • USB rechargeable • Discreet for wear • $79.99
Wearing a Plug During Other Activities
During solo play
One of the most popular uses of an anal plug is wearing it during masturbation or other solo stimulation. The sensation of anal fullness alongside genital stimulation uses the shared nerve pathways between the anal and genital areas, often significantly intensifying orgasm. For people with a prostate, the sustained indirect prostate pressure during other stimulation is a particularly common and popular combination.
During partnered sex
Wearing a plug during penetrative sex, oral sex, or manual stimulation with a partner adds a layer of sensation for the plug wearer that many people describe as noticeably increasing arousal intensity and orgasm strength. For couples, both partners wearing plugs simultaneously during sex is increasingly popular as a way to add a shared sensory experience to an existing routine.
For extended or adventurous wear
Some people wear plugs for extended periods — around the house, during everyday activities, or in specific scenarios as part of a power dynamic or kink practice. If you're exploring extended wear, start with shorter periods to understand your body's response, use a comfortable, body-safe silicone plug rather than firmer materials for prolonged wear, and remove and clean the plug if you feel any discomfort, numbness, or pressure that isn't pleasurable.
Cleaning and Care
After every single use
Clean immediately after use without exception. Warm water and dedicated toy cleaner is the standard approach for silicone, ABS plastic, and most materials. Some non-motorised silicone plugs can be boiled for full sterilisation; check the manufacturer's instructions. Metal and glass plugs can be boiled, run through a dishwasher, or soaked in a diluted bleach solution for complete sterilisation between users.
Between partners
Never share an anal toy between partners without thorough cleaning or, better, without using a new condom on the toy for each partner. Anal toys can transmit bacteria and STIs between partners even if both appear asymptomatic.
Storage
Store clean, dry, and separately from other toys where possible — particularly avoid silicone-on-silicone storage, which can cause surface degradation over time. The pouch or box your toy comes in is usually the best storage solution.
Frequently Asked Questions — Sydney
Is it normal to feel nervous about trying an anal plug for the first time?
Completely normal — and worth acknowledging directly, because anxiety and physical tension are functionally connected. A nervous, tense body resists anal insertion regardless of how much preparation has occurred. The steps in this guide are specifically ordered to address this: choosing the right moment, beginning with external stimulation, and using generous lubrication all work together to create the relaxed physical state that makes first-time plug use comfortable rather than difficult. If you try and it doesn't go well the first time, that's extremely common — try again in a more relaxed setting.
What's the best anal plug to start with in Sydney?
The Selopa Petite Plug ($19.99) is our top recommendation for an absolute first plug — 7.4cm, slim, smooth silicone, and at a price that means there's minimal risk in simply trying it. The Silver Starter ($29.99) is a close second for those who want a more aesthetically appealing first plug without spending more than necessary.
Do I need to douche before using an anal plug?
Not necessarily — for shorter plug sessions, most people find a simple warm shower beforehand is sufficient. Douching provides extra cleanliness assurance that some people prefer for longer sessions or for partnered play where hygiene anxiety is a factor. If you do douche, use only warm water and allow 30–60 minutes afterward before play. Don't over-douche (multiple rounds back-to-back) as this can strip natural rectal moisture.
Can a plug get stuck or lost internally?
A properly designed anal plug with a flared base cannot travel inside the body — the flared base is wider than the anal opening and physically prevents this. This is the reason the flared base rule in this guide is described as non-negotiable. If you ever struggle to remove a plug — which is rare with correct sizing and lubrication — bearing down gently while relaxing, and applying additional lubricant around the base, will almost always resolve it. If a toy without a proper base has been used and cannot be retrieved, seek medical attention at an emergency department without embarrassment — this is a situation medical staff have encountered many times and will handle without judgement.
Can I use a plug if I'm new to anal play entirely?
Yes — a properly sized, beginner-appropriate plug is actually one of the gentlest and most controlled introductions to anal play available, because it doesn't involve thrusting or partner movement. It provides a sustained, manageable sensation that can be removed at any point. Starting with a slim plug like the Selopa Petite is a sensible first step before exploring anything larger or more involved.
Are anal plugs safe to use with condoms on the toy?
Yes — and using a condom on a plug (changed between uses or between partners) is a valid additional hygiene measure, particularly for porous materials or when sharing between partners. Use a standard non-lubricated condom over the plug, with water-based lubricant applied on top of the condom. For body-safe non-porous silicone plugs, condom use is optional but adds a layer of hygiene reassurance some people prefer.
What lubricant is best for anal plug use in Sydney?
A dedicated water-based anal lubricant is the best all-round choice — thicker than standard water-based lube, longer-lasting, and safe with silicone toys. The Wicked Simply Timeless Aqua Jelle is a reliable water-based anal formula available in Sydney with same-day dispatch. Avoid oil-based lubricants with silicone toys, and avoid very thin water-based formulas that dry out quickly during use.
How long can I safely wear a plug?
For most people using a comfortable, body-safe silicone plug, wearing for 30–60 minutes during a play session is a sensible range for regular use. Extended wear beyond this is practised by many experienced users, but should be built up gradually with attention to how the body responds. Always remove if there's any numbness, sharp pain, or discomfort that isn't pleasurable. Never sleep with a plug in unless you have significant experience with extended wear and have established this is safe and comfortable for your body specifically.
Can anal plugs be used by people of all genders?
Yes. Anal plugs are one of the most gender-inclusive toys in the adult toy category — the anatomy of nerve distribution and the basic mechanism of sensation apply across all anatomies. For people with a prostate, there's an additional prostate stimulation element; for those without, the pleasure comes from the anal nerve endings and shared pelvic nerve pathways regardless. Sex Toys Sydney's anal plug range includes options designed with inclusivity in mind across sizing, aesthetics, and marketing.
How quickly does delivery to Sydney take?
Sex Toys Sydney dispatches same-day on orders placed before 2pm AEST, with most Sydney metro orders arriving within 1–3 business days. Every order ships in completely plain, unmarked packaging with no branding or indication of contents, and billing references on bank statements are discreet.
Explore Our Anal Toy Range in Sydney
- Shop all anal toys Sydney
- Shop anal toys for women Sydney
- Shop prostate massagers Sydney
- Shop lubricants & lotions Sydney
- Shop women's sex toys Sydney
Ready to explore? Visit Sex Toys Sydney — Sydney's biggest online adult store. Discreet delivery across Sydney and Australia-wide. Australian owned since 2002.